Commonwealth v. Norman Simmons
Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts
383 Mass. 40; 417 N.E.2d 430; 1981 Mass. LEXIS 1130
November 4, 1980, Argued
February 26, 1981, Decided
COUNSEL: William J. Leahy for the defendant.
Matthew L. McGrant, III, Assistant District Attorney (Michael J. Traft, Assistant District Attorney, with him) for the Commonwealth.
JUDGES: Hennessey, C.J., Braucher, Kaplan, Wilkins, & Abrams, JJ.
OPINION BY: HENNESSEY
OPINION
This is an appeal, on direct appellate review, from the defendant’s manslaughter conviction. The defendant’s several assignments of error all relate to the trial judge’s charge to the jury. We conclude that there was no error and affirm the judgment.
We summarize the evidence. The defendant had an argument and a fist fight with the victim, Allen Williams, on the afternoon of March 25, 1978, near the Cathedral housing project in Boston. Both men left the scene; there was some evidence that they promised or threatened each other that each would return with weapons. Soon thereafter, both met in the courtyard of the housing project, Williams armed with a gun and the defendant armed with a knife, variously described as a steak knife and a butcher knife.
At the second confrontation, Williams died of a stab wound to his heart and lungs caused by a single blow struck by the defendant with his knife. There was conflicting evidence whether Williams had taken his gun from his pocket before he was stabbed. The defendant testified that he struck at Williams with a knife to protect himself, after Williams had pointed the gun at him and pistol-whipped him across the bridge of his nose.
Two witnesses testified as to the defendant’s reputation as a peaceable person, and his reputation as a truthful person. One of these witnesses also testified that the victim Williams had a reputation for violence and aggression, and the defendant stated that he armed himself with a knife to defend himself, with the knowledge that Williams had been dishonorably discharged from the armed forces and had a reputation for intimidating younger people in the neighborhood.
The defendant urges that there was error in the judge’s instructions to the jury as to the evidence of the defendant’s character, and error in the instructions as to self-defense. Further, error is alleged by reason of the judge’s failure to give a specific instruction on the victim’s character, as requested by the defendant. The defendant made a proper and timely objection as to only one of these areas, the judge’s refusal to specifically instruct as to the victim’s character. Thus, as to all but the one issue, our duty to review extends only far enough to guard against a miscarriage of justice. See Commonwealth v. Freeman, 352 Mass. 556, 563-564 (1967). However, we need not concern ourselves further with this aspect since, judged by the usual appellate standard of review, there is no error and no ground for relief.
At the close of the evidence, the defendant requested the judge to instruct the jury as to evidence of the defendant’s peaceful character, and Williams’ reputation for violence. The requested peaceful character instruction read: “Evidence of the defendant’s good and peaceful character, like all other evidence in the case, should be considered by the jury; and if therefrom a reasonable doubt is generated in the mind of the jury as to the guilt of the accused, it is your duty to find him not guilty.”
The defendant asserts that Commonwealth v. Leonard, 140 Mass. 473, 479-481 (1886), settled the law of this Commonwealth that evidence of good character as to a relevant trait of the defendant may alone generate a reasonable doubt as to guilt, and that the jury must be so instructed upon request. We think that the defendant misconstrues Leonard, which held that when evidence of character is admissible, its weight should be left to be determined by the jury in connection with all the other evidence in the case. The importance of Leonard is that it eliminated the old practice of charging juries that evidence of character was of little or no weight, except in cases where guilt remained doubtful after consideration of the other evidence. While the judge could appropriately have given the instruction as the defendant requested, he was not required to do so. The judge adequately complied with the requirements of Commonwealth v. Wilson, 152 Mass. 12 (1890), which well states the instructions to which a defendant is entitled on this issue. 1 In Wilson, the court concluded that the judge’s charge adequately covered the subject, where it appeared that the instruction stated, “[The jury] ought properly to consider in connection with other evidence for the defendant such testimony relative to his character . . .,” id. at 14, and at another point in this charge the judge instructed that the burden was upon the Commonwealth to prove all allegations beyond a reasonable doubt. The first paragraph of the related instructions in the instant case, read together with the judge’s unimpeachable statements as to burden of proof, satisfied the requirements as stated in Wilson.
1 On this aspect the charge was as follows: “In addition to [the defendant’s criminal record], the defendant has introduced evidence of his general reputation in the community. Such evidence may indicate to you that it is improbable that a person of such good character would commit the crime as charged, and therefore, you should consider this evidence along with all other evidence in the case, in determining the guilt or innocence of the defendant.
“Equally so, you may find — and I submit to you another hypothetical example — that the mere fact that there are individuals in the community, or a community, that find a person to be of good character does not in itself absolve a person from the commission of any crime. I’m sure each and every one of you seated on the panel today, have many in your community who will come forward and attest to your good character. It may be equally true that under certain circumstances you still may be inclined, or might be compelled, to commit a crime.
“So you must weigh that, not only as to the good character of the defendant and his believability, and you weigh that along with the criminal record that was introduced by way of stipulation. Keep in mind the warning that I have given you and the instruction that I have given you, that the criminal record of the defendant is not to be used in determining his guilt or innocence.”
Nor do we agree with the defendant in his assertion that the judge improperly diluted the instructions by his related remarks subsequent to the first paragraph. These statements were essentially only variations upon the same theme: that the character evidence was to be considered together with all the other evidence. 2
2 The defendant also argues that the judge in the final words of this part of the charge prejudicially confused the jury as to the use of character evidence on the issue of guilt or innocence, as compared to the limited use of prior criminal convictions of the defendant on the issue of his credibility only. While the phrasing is not beyond criticism, we find no error, in light of the fact that two witnesses testified both as to the defendant’s reputation as peaceable and his reputation for credibility. The testimony was thus juxtaposed much as the judge grouped it in his charge. Further, the judge carefully concluded this portion of the charge by instructing the jury to limit the use of the evidence of prior convictions to the credibility issue.
We conclude, also, that there was no error in the judge’s denial of the defendant’s request for an instruction to the jury specifically concerning the victim’s character. The instruction might properly have been given; there was no requirement that it be given. The judge’s charge was appropriate and sufficient on the state of mind of the defendant as it related to self-defense. The instruction stated that the defendant “must justifiably repel force with force, as long as the danger appears to exist . . . if he . . . reasonably believes that his life or bodily safety is in danger, he may do whatever he naturally and honestly believes is necessary to protect himself.” These words sufficiently informed the jury that they should consider “the nature of the provocation under which the defendant acted, and the influence it had on the mind of the defendant, as showing a reasonable apprehension.” Commonwealth v. Tircinski, 189 Mass. 257, 257 (1905). The judge need not instruct as to every possible inference. Commonwealth v. Polian, 288 Mass. 494, 499 (1934). Whether to give the requested instruction lay in the usual discretion of the judge to decide to what extent he will state the evidence and discuss the possible issues of fact. See Commonwealth v. Venuti, 315 Mass. 255, 261 (1943). A party has no right to require the judge to argue the case.
Finally, we do not agree with the defendant’s argument that the judge’s instructions to the jury impermissibly shifted the burden of proof to the defendant on the issue of self-defense. It is true that the instructions contained several references to the “defense” of self-defense. In his charge on self-defense, the judge also stated to the jury that “you must find” and “the defendant claims,” and we have in more than one case disapproved of such terminology, even if used infrequently, as in this case. See, e.g., Connolly v. Commonwealth, 377 Mass. 527, 533-534 (1979). Nevertheless, there was no error here, in light of our principle that a narrow and precise test is not to be applied to the charge, but rather the charge to the jury must be examined in its entirety. Commonwealth v. Stokes, 374 Mass. 583, 590-591 (1978). In the course of his charge the judge specifically instructed, in unequivocal language on four separate occasions, that the Commonwealth had to show the absence of self-defense. Cf. Commonwealth v. Hodge (No. 2), 380 Mass. 858, 865-866 (1980); Lannon v. Commonwealth, 379 Mass. 786, 791-792 (1980); Gibson v. Commonwealth, 377 Mass. 539 (1979). Cases like Commonwealth v. Collins, 374 Mass. 596 (1978), and Commonwealth v. Rodriguez, 370 Mass. 684 (1976), relied on by the defendant, are clearly distinguishable.
In sum, the judge’s charge to the jury was free of reversible error.
Judgment affirmed.
Pingback: What GPA do I need to get a full scholarship
Pingback: Human Resources Management courses
Pingback: Marketing research
Pingback: ????? ??????????
Pingback: E-Learning
Pingback: Pharmaceutical Analytical Chemistry
Pingback: madridbet
Pingback: madridbet
Pingback: meritking
Pingback: meritking
Pingback: meritking
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: https://www.kooky.domains/post/what-are-web3-domains
Pingback: https://www.kooky.domains/post/the-basics-of-web3-domains-and-decentralized-applications
Pingback: https://www.kooky.domains/post/privacy-oriented-web3-domains
Pingback: درجات البكالوريوس في الموارد البشرية
Pingback: Management information systems program
Pingback: برنامج الموارد البشرية
Pingback: كلية الاقتصاد والعلوم السياسية
Pingback: Economic Internship
Pingback: Local society
Pingback: meritking
Pingback: Dissolution apparatus
Pingback: كم عدد سنوات كلية الصيدلة
Pingback: Dental care services
Pingback: Oral health
Pingback: meritking giriş
Pingback: تخصصات طب الأسنان بعد البكالوريوس
Pingback: the role played by the students of the College of Engineering to advance the country
Pingback: البحث والابتكار
Pingback: Student Success
Pingback: Job Opportunities in Computer Science
Pingback: Organizing "Egypt in a Changing World" Conference
Pingback: Dr. Khaled Azazy
Pingback: MBA in FUE
Pingback: Online MBA program in Egypt
Pingback: خطابات توصية لجامعة المستقبل
Pingback: متطلبات كشف الدرجات لجامعة المستقبل
Pingback: Maillot de football
Pingback: Maillot de football
Pingback: Maillot de football
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: porn
Pingback: SEOSolutionVIP Fiverr
Pingback: SEOSolutionVIP Fiverr
Pingback: SEOSolutionVIP Fiverr
Pingback: porn
Pingback: strisce a led per cucina
Pingback: pannelli luci led
Pingback: seated dip
Pingback: arm extension
Pingback: structure ninja warrior
Pingback: cage de mma
Pingback: prostadine
Pingback: Fiverr Earn
Pingback: Fiverr Earn
Pingback: Fiverr Earn
Pingback: Fiverr Earn
Pingback: Fiverr Earn
Pingback: Fiverr Earn
Pingback: Fiverr Earn
Pingback: Fiverr Earn
Pingback: fiverrearn.com
Pingback: fiverrearn.com
Pingback: fiverrearn.com
Pingback: fiverrearn.com
Pingback: fiverrearn.com
Pingback: fiverrearn.com
Pingback: Advance-Esthetic LLC
Pingback: fiverrearn.com
Pingback: fiverrearn.com
Pingback: 3pl Broker
Pingback: french bulldog houston tx
Pingback: clothes manufacturing
Pingback: clothes manufacturing
Pingback: clima
Pingback: fiverrearn.com
Pingback: puppies french bulldog
Pingback: french bulldog pimples around mouth
Pingback: is coconut oil good for french bulldogs
Pingback: springer doodle
Pingback: exotic bully
Pingback: fluffy bully
Pingback: teacup french bulldog
Pingback: vacation rental isla mujeres
Pingback: jute rugs
Pingback: seo in United States
Pingback: seo in Saudi Arabia
Pingback: SMM
Pingback: Piano Freight London
Pingback: Piano Disassembly and Assembly
Pingback: Professional Piano Disposal
Pingback: Top university in Egypt
Pingback: Best university in Egypt
Pingback: Top university in Egypt
Pingback: Private universities in Egypt
Pingback: Best university in Egypt
Pingback: Top university in Egypt
Pingback: Private universities in Egypt
Pingback: isla mahara
Pingback: isla mujeres rental
Pingback: merle french bulldog
Pingback: frenchie doodle
Pingback: chocolate fawn french bulldog
Pingback: blue fawn french bulldog
Pingback: french bulldog vs pug
Pingback: can frenchies eat bread
Pingback: black french bulldog
Pingback: french bulldog stud
Pingback: blockchain
Pingback: vietnam visa requirements for us citizens
Pingback: teacup frenchie
Pingback: micro blue french bulldog
Pingback: Phone repair Orange County
Pingback: french bulldogs for sale tx
Pingback: Sterling silver heart earrings
Pingback: future university
Pingback: future university
Pingback: future university
Pingback: future university
Pingback: multisbo link alternatif
Pingback: isla mujeres golf cart rentals
Pingback: french bulldogs puppys
Pingback: Fiverr.Com
Pingback: Fiverr
Pingback: gray french bulldogs
Pingback: fue
Pingback: french bulldog puppies
Pingback: bulldog frenchie puppies
Pingback: isla mujeres rental golf cart
Pingback: lean manufacturing
Pingback: french bulldogs houston for sale
Pingback: french bulldog sale san antonio
Pingback: FUE
Pingback: FUE
Pingback: FUE
Pingback: FUE
Pingback: FUE
Pingback: FUE
Pingback: FUE
Pingback: FUE
Pingback: FUE
Pingback: FUE
Pingback: Moving assistance
Pingback: Local movers
Pingback: yourrewardcard.com activate
Pingback: bali indonesia
Pingback: برنامج ادارة الاعمال بمصر
Pingback: Classic Books 500
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: Fiverr.Com
Pingback: Fiverr.Com
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: Speaker
Pingback: Media
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: Porn stars Australia
Pingback: pupuk cair
Pingback: pupuk anorganik
Pingback: Pupuk Organik terbaik dan terpercaya hanya melalui pupukanorganik.com
Pingback: pupuk organik terbaik
Pingback: Unisex Exclusive Design Tees/Apparel
Pingback: partners
Pingback: weight loss supplements
Pingback: sleep support supplements
Pingback: how to improve digestion naturally
Pingback: metaboflex
Pingback: xitox website
Pingback: third eye supplement
Pingback: gluconite website
Pingback: افضل كلية سياسة في مصر
Pingback: french bulldog pups for sale near me
Pingback: Predictions
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: live sex cams
Pingback: live sex cams
Pingback: live sex cams
Pingback: live sex cams
Pingback: live sex cams
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: texas french bulldogs
Pingback: french bulldog houston
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: Best University in Yemen
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: სერიალები ქართულად
Pingback: ფილმები ქართულად
Pingback: Supper
Pingback: seo company pennsylvania
Pingback: email
Pingback: science
Pingback: Slot Thailand
Pingback: Slot Online
Pingback: Scientific Research
Pingback: Kuliah Termurah
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: FiverrEarn
Pingback: Generator Service Leeds
Pingback: sumatra tonic scam
Pingback: cheap sex cams
Pingback: fullersears.com
Pingback: fullersears.com
Pingback: french bulldog buy
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: live sex cams
Pingback: live sex cams
Pingback: live sex cams
Pingback: marketplace
Pingback: Freeze dried water
Pingback: rare breed-trigger
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: efos y edos
Pingback: morocco desert travel
Pingback: hire car with driver
Pingback: 늑대닷컴
Pingback: Slot progresif
Pingback: nangs near me
Pingback: superslot
Pingback: SEO services Singapore
Pingback: allgame
Pingback: 918kiss
Pingback: หวย24
Pingback: Hair care
Pingback: pg slot
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: leak detection london
Pingback: artificial intelligence lawyer
Pingback: cybersécurité
Pingback: Raahe Guide
Pingback: aplikasi slot
Pingback: Life Coach Chelsea
Pingback: upstate hotels
Pingback: health supplements
Pingback: health and wellness products
Pingback: cratosroyalbet
Pingback: megagame
Pingback: evisa
Pingback: ozempic
Pingback: sicarios en españa
Pingback: itsMasum.Com
Pingback: itsMasum.Com
Pingback: itsMasum.Com
Pingback: mail frauduleux signaler
Pingback: ingénieur informatique salaire
Pingback: formations rémunérées
Pingback: keylogger
Pingback: salaire ingénieur suisse
Pingback: FÜHRERSCHEIN SCHWEIZ (CH)
Pingback: quick nangs delivery
Pingback: nangs Sydney
Pingback: chauffe eau Tours
Pingback: website
Pingback: website
Pingback: itsmasum.com
Pingback: chatwi
Pingback: online chat rooms
Pingback: online chat
Pingback: itsmasum.com
Pingback: itsmasum.com
Pingback: itsmasum.com
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: joker gaming
Pingback: Film institutionnel Nantes
Pingback: minneapolis jobs
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: sex cams
Pingback: free webcam sex
Pingback: Kampus Islami
Pingback: spinco
Pingback: Queen Arwa University World University Rankings THE
Pingback: Queen Arwa University digital identity
Pingback: 918kiss
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: pg slot
Pingback: 918kiss
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: fuck google
Pingback: ItMe.Xyz
Pingback: Bulk URL Shortener
Pingback: itme.xyz
Pingback: itme.xyz
Pingback: FB URL Shortener
Pingback: ItMe.Xyz
Pingback: Dropbox URL Shortener
Pingback: Dropbox URL Shortener
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: mzplay
Pingback: wix seo expert
Pingback: chanel dog bowl
Pingback: de zaragoza
Pingback: chimalhuacan
Pingback: blue french bulldog
Pingback: frenchie puppies for sale california
Pingback: cheap sex cams
Pingback: free nude chat
Pingback: free webcam sex
Pingback: live video chat
Pingback: french pitbull puppy
Pingback: in vitro fertilization mexico
Pingback: french bulldog texas
Pingback: floodle puppies for sale
Pingback: fertility acupuncture nj
Pingback: porn
Pingback: culiacan clima
Pingback: clima en neza
Pingback: vietravel tour
Pingback: linh hoang
Pingback: liz kerr
Pingback: porn
Pingback: hd porn
Pingback: cuautitlan izcalli clima
Pingback: Eaton
Pingback: frenchies for sale in texas
Pingback: بطاقة ايوا
Pingback: sex cams
Pingback: yorkie poo breeding
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: play net app
Pingback: cancun mexico boat rental
Pingback: 스포츠중계
Pingback: 스포츠분석
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: best probiotic for french bulldogs
Pingback: blockchain
Pingback: esports domains
Pingback: french bulldog rescue
Pingback: dog registry
Pingback: undetected spoofer tool
Pingback: undetected rust cheats
Pingback: undetected cheat site
Pingback: download finals cheats
Pingback: chamy rim dips
Pingback: candy factory
Pingback: moped rental isla mujeres
Pingback: best french bulldog breeder
Pingback: french bulldog puppies for sale $200
Pingback: lilac frenchies
Pingback: black frenchies
Pingback: dump him shirt
Pingback: porn
Pingback: hairdresser in houston
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: richest vietnamese in america
Pingback: 늑대닷컴
Pingback: joyce echols
Pingback: massachusetts boston terriers
Pingback: dog probiotic chews
Pingback: spam
Pingback: dr kim acupuncture
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: we buy french bulldog puppies
Pingback: mexican candy store near me
Pingback: mexican candy store near me
Pingback: french bulldog texas
Pingback: mexican candy store near me
Pingback: mexican candy store near me
Pingback: mexican candy store near me
Pingback: mexican candy store near me
Pingback: linh hoang
Pingback: surrogacy mexico
Pingback: french bulldog shop
Pingback: coco chanel dog collar
Pingback: crypto news
Pingback: magnolia brazilian jiu jitsu
Pingback: bjj houston tx
Pingback: french bulldog
Pingback: french bulldog
Pingback: minnect expert
Pingback: boston terrier french bulldog mix
Pingback: best canine probiotics for bullies
Pingback: french bulldog pug mix
Pingback: french bulldog chihuahua mix
Pingback: floodle
Pingback: Dog Registry
Pingback: Dog Registry
Pingback: How To Obtain Dog Papers
Pingback: How To Obtain Dog Papers
Pingback: How To Get My Dog Papers
Pingback: Dog Registry
Pingback: Dog Papers
Pingback: How To Get My Dog Papers
Pingback: Dog Registry
Pingback: Dog Papers
Pingback: Dog Registry
Pingback: Dog Registry
Pingback: Dog Papers
Pingback: Dog Papers
Pingback: Dog Registry
Pingback: Dog Papers
Pingback: Dog Registry
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: best seo companies in houston
Pingback: dog registration
Pingback: french bulldog texas
Pingback: golf cart rentals isla mujeres
Pingback: French Bulldog Rescue
Pingback: French Bulldog Adoption
Pingback: French Bulldog Rescue
Pingback: French Bulldog Rescue
Pingback: French Bulldog Adoption
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: bulldog shih tzu mix
Pingback: clima en atizapán de zaragoza
Pingback: grey fluffy french bulldog
Pingback: playnet download
Pingback: chile candies
Pingback: golf cart rentals
Pingback: beach golf cart rental
Pingback: French Bulldog Puppies Near Me
Pingback: French Bulldog Puppies Near Me
Pingback: Frenchie Puppies
Pingback: French Bulldog Puppies Near Me
Pingback: French Bulldog For Sale
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: best probiotic for english bulldog
Pingback: probiotic dog treats
Pingback: Fort Lee
Pingback: fertility acupuncture
Pingback: kingroyal porn
Pingback: crypto news
Pingback: brazil crop top
Pingback: chanel dog bowl
Pingback: leo constellation necklace
Pingback: pickle ball tote
Pingback: bulldog pins
Pingback: need money for porsche shirt
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: frenchie chihuahua mix
Pingback: floodle puppies for sale
Pingback: frenchie chihuahua mix
Pingback: floodle puppies for sale